Extra Credit: The Twilight Saga and domestic abuse | Yes, I Read It. It's Still Stupid.
In which the themes of abuse in Twilight are examined a little more critically. Bella, as well, exhibits signs of someone who is abused. Twilight series is the worst example of abusive relationships in the urban fantasy genre. Abusive Relationships In Twilight examples of abuse in twilight 1. Being controlling/Stalker 2. Asserting dominance to instill fear 3. Jealousy. A look at what Twilight says about relationships, domestic abuse and up the warning signs of domestic violence and abusive relationships.
Abusers will threaten violence on their victims in order to exert further control.
In the Twilight series, this is a little more subtle and insidious. Edward warns Bella that he could hurt her, that he could lose control at any moment. In chapter 8 of Twilight, he admits to having murderous thoughts regarding the ruffians Bella was accosted by, to further illustrate how dangerous he is. Even more shocking, he tells Bella later that he wanted to kill her when they first met. Abusers will often try to scare their victims into submission.
Edward in chapter 13 of Twilight, jumping around, smashing trees, showing off how fast and strong he is, in an attempt to make Bella frightened of him. Do I really need to say more? Abusers are very good at making their own excuses for their actions, and shifting the blame. Again, this is a little more subtle in the Twilight series. Edward blames his behavior on being a vampire, on having to resist human blood, and on having buried his humanity for so long.
They will make it up to the abused in whatever way they can, in an attempt to keep the victim with them. Then he refuses to let her drive and warns of the threat of violence if she open-mouth kisses him.
Is Twilight Making Abuse Sexy? | HuffPost
Bella, as well, exhibits signs of someone who is abused. She accepts the blame readily when terrible things happen, especially when it was through no fault of her own. She has incredibly low self-esteem, and considers herself lucky to be with Edward.
She is always ready with an excuse when Edward begins to treat her coldly, hurts her, or otherwise emotionally abuses her.
It can be insidious, as the abusers are often very good at hiding their behavior from others, or even convincing others that they should be excused from what they do, due to everything from a bad childhood to a bad day. Emotional abuse is unfortunately the most ignored, as it leaves no obvious bruises or scars. Victims will assume that since their partner has not put them in the hospital, there is no abuse occurring at all.
Seeing it occur so blatantly in Twilight, a book that is shoved down the throats of young girls as a model romance, honestly makes me scared. It makes me sick. Related This entry was posted on May 10, at 1: You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.
Is Twilight Making Abuse Sexy?
But abuse is a bit more complicated. How do you speak to kids about emotional abuse of a partner or self-abuse with eating disorders?10 Gaslighting Signs in an Abusive Relationship
Gigi Meenakshi Durham is a researcher who investigated the Twilight Saga and looked at gender stereotypes and dating activities and customs. She also found that the Twilight series presents a troubling view of gender roles in which females are helpless and require male protection and that there are many parallels between the attitudes of women in battering relationships. In the films and texts, the author identified five themes: I would also add the following unhealthy ideals presented in the series: Bella is often brutally bruised and sore from Edward's vampire strength.
10 signs of an abusive relationship – a Twilight reading
Instead of being horrified by these injuries, her character wears them as proud battle wounds symbolizing her love for Edward. Another unhealthy relationship behavior in the book is Edward's penchant for watching Bella sleep.
The character often sneaks into Bella's room to watch her during the night. In the book, this is shown as romantic, but in real life it would be both creepy and unhealthy.
Bella's relationship with Jacob also takes on some abusive undertones.
Abusive Relationships In Twilight by Taylor Pashovitz on Prezi
I'll kill you myself! I'll do it now! This kind of threat and idea is dangerous. When Bella is human she is never hungry. She never eats and is always saying that her stomach is just too filled with 'butterflies' to eat.