St john and jane eyres relationship problems

The presentation and significance of Jane's relationship with St John | Essay Example

Jane continues to pay attention to the relationship between St. John and Rosamond, who often visits the school when she knows St. John will be there. The main issue between St. John and Jane is the fact that he wants to marry When it came to marriage with Rochester, that represented the true meaning of. I hope your energies will then once more trouble you with their strength." .. "St. John! you used to call Jane your third sister, but you don't treat her as such: you.

He opens to Jane the possibility of exercising her talents fully by working and living with him in India. Jane eventually realizes, though, that this freedom would also constitute a form of imprisonment, because she would be forced to keep her true feelings and her true passions always in check.

St Johns proposal can be characterized as unromantic and oppressing since he practically forces Jane to marry him. Throughout his proposal St John is passionate and talks with great deal for God, heaven etc. This behaviour suffocates Jane bringing her to the point of asking for mercy.

St John tells her that God needs her and he is testing her faith to God. St John is self-interested and pressures Jane he says he claims her. For every negative answer by Jane, St John seems to have planned what to say next.

Why St. John Rivers Isn't Just a Jerk in Jane Eyre | Torrey Honors Institute, Biola University

St John supports his answers and points by using the Bible and generally God. St John has been observing and studying Jane to see if she is right for the job and has planned everything from the very beginning. St John uses emotional blackmail that tortures Jane mentally.

He wants to marry Jane so he can influence her life till her death. The whole thing is a matter of control. The more he speaks the more Jane feels his influence on her. She feels like she cant do anything to escape. St John is arrogant; he strongly believes Jane should become a part of him.

This is what he wants and this is how he wants it. Jane reacts to all these in a passionate and outspoken way. She is not prepared to be controlled or oppressed by anyone. This incident brings up to the surface the character of Jane. She is direct, unconventional and opinionated. St John wants to marry Jane not on the idea of love but on the idea that he has to because of obedience to God.

The more he pressures Jane, the further she goes away. She does not want to marry St John due to his reasons and purposes, she wants a marriage full of love and trust and not one that is just there so St John can go on a missionary.

It was now dark; but a rumbling of wheels was audible. Hannah soon had a lantern lit. The vehicle had stopped at the wicket; the driver opened the door: In a minute I had my face under their bonnets, in contact first with Mary's soft cheek, then with Diana's flowing curls.

They laughed — kissed me — then Hannah: They were stiff with their long and jolting drive from Whitcross, and chilled with the frosty night air; but their pleasant countenances expanded to the cheerful firelight. While the driver and Hannah brought in the boxes, they demanded St. At this moment he advanced from the parlour. They both threw their arms round his neck at once.

He gave each one quiet kiss, said in a low tone a few words of welcome, stood a while to be talked to, and then, intimating that he supposed they would soon rejoin him in the parlour, withdrew there as to a place of refuge. I had lit their candles to go upstairs, but Diana had first to give hospitable orders respecting the driver; this done, both followed me. They were delighted with the renovation and decorations of their rooms; with the new drapery, and fresh carpets, and rich tinted china vases: I had the pleasure of feeling that my arrangements met their wishes exactly, and that what I had done added a vivid charm to their joyous return home.

Sweet was that evening. My cousins, full of exhilaration, were so eloquent in narrative and comment, that their fluency covered St. The event of the day — that is, the return of Diana and Mary — pleased him; but the accompaniments of that event, the glad tumult, the garrulous glee of reception irked him: I saw he wished the calmer morrow was come.

In the very meridian of the night's enjoyment, about an hour after tea, a rap was heard at the door. Hannah entered with the intimation that "a poor lad was come, at that unlikely time, to fetch Mr.

Rivers to see his mother, who was drawing away. It's the worst road to travel after dark that can be: And then it is such a bitter night — the keenest wind you ever felt.

You had better send word, sir, that you will be there in the morning. It was then nine o'clock: Starved and tired enough he was: He had performed an act of duty; made an exertion; felt his own strength to do and deny, and was on better terms with himself. I am afraid the whole of the ensuing week tried his patience. It was Christmas week: The air of the moors, the freedom of home, the dawn of prosperity, acted on Diana and Mary's spirits like some life-giving elixir: They could always talk; and their discourse, witty, pithy, original, had such charms for me, that I preferred listening to, and sharing in it, to doing anything else.

John did not rebuke our vivacity; but he escaped from it: One morning at breakfast, Diana, after looking a little pensive for some minutes, asked him, "If his plans were yet unchanged. And he proceeded to inform us that his departure from England was now definitively fixed for the ensuing year.

John had a book in his hand — it was his unsocial custom to read at meals — he closed it, and looked up. Granby, one of the best connected and most estimable residents in S- grandson and heir to Sir Frederic Granby: I had the intelligence from her father yesterday. But where there are no obstacles to a union, as in the present case, where the connection is in every point desirable, delays are unnecessary: John alone after this communication, I felt tempted to inquire if the event distressed him: Besides, I was out of practice in talking to him: He had not kept his promise of treating me like his sisters; he continually made little chilling differences between us, which did not at all tend to the development of cordiality: When I remembered how far I had once been admitted to his confidence, I could hardly comprehend his present frigidity.

Such being the case, I felt not a little surprised when he raised his head suddenly from the desk over which he was stooping, and said — "You see, Jane, the battle is fought and the victory won.

Would not such another ruin you? The event of the conflict is decisive: As our mutual happiness i. John stayed more at home: While Mary drew, Diana pursued a course of encyclopaedic reading she had to my awe and amazement undertaken, and I fagged away at German, he pondered a mystic lore of his own: Thus engaged, he appeared, sitting in his own recess, quiet and absorbed enough; but that blue eye of his had a habit of leaving the outlandish- looking grammar, and wandering over, and sometimes fixing upon us, his fellow-students, with a curious intensity of observation: I wondered what it meant: I wondered, too, at the punctual satisfaction he never failed to exhibit on an occasion that seemed to me of small moment, namely, my weekly visit to Morton school; and still more was I puzzled when, if the day was unfavourable, if there was snow, or rain, or high wind, and his sisters urged me not to go, he would invariably make light of their solicitude, and encourage me to accomplish the task without regard to the elements.

Her constitution is both sound and elastic; — better calculated to endure variations of climate than many more robust. One afternoon, however, I got leave to stay at home, because I really had a cold. His sisters were gone to Morton in my stead: I sat reading Schiller; he, deciphering his crabbed Oriental scrolls. As I exchanged a translation for an exercise, I happened to look his way: How long it had been searching me through and through, and over and over, I cannot tell: Would I do him this favour?

I should not, perhaps, have to make the sacrifice long, as it wanted now barely three months to his departure. John was not a man to be lightly refused: When Diana and Mary returned, the former found her scholar transferred from her to her brother: John should never have persuaded them to such a step.

The presentation and significance of Jane’s relationship with St John Essay Sample

He answered quietly — "I know it. By degrees, he acquired a certain influence over me that took away my liberty of mind: I could no longer talk or laugh freely when he was by, because a tiresomely importunate instinct reminded me that vivacity at least in me was distasteful to him.

I was so fully aware that only serious moods and occupations were acceptable, that in his presence every effort to sustain or follow any other became vain: I fell under a freezing spell.

When he said "go," I went; "come," I came; "do this," I did it. But I did not love my servitude: I wished, many a time, he had continued to neglect me. One evening when, at bedtime, his sisters and I stood round him, bidding him good-night, he kissed each of them, as was his custom; and, as was equally his custom, he gave me his hand.

Diana, who chanced to be in a frolicsome humour she was not painfully controlled by his will; for hers, in another way, was as strongexclaimed — "St.

I thought Diana very provoking, and felt uncomfortably confused; and while I was thus thinking and feeling, St. John bent his head; his Greek face was brought to a level with mine, his eyes questioned my eyes piercingly — he kissed me. There are no such things as marble kisses or ice kisses, or I should say my ecclesiastical cousin's salute belonged to one of these classes; but there may be experiment kisses, and his was an experiment kiss. When given, he viewed me to learn the result; it was not striking: I am sure I did not blush; perhaps I might have turned a little pale, for I felt as if this kiss were a seal affixed to my fetters.

He never omitted the ceremony afterwards, and the gravity and quiescence with which I underwent it, seemed to invest it for him with a certain charm. As for me, I daily wished more to please him; but to do so, I felt daily more and more that I must disown half my nature, stifle half my faculties, wrest my tastes from their original bent, force myself to the adoption of pursuits for which I had no natural vocation. He wanted to train me to an elevation I could never reach; it racked me hourly to aspire to the standard he uplifted.

The thing was as impossible as to mould my irregular features to his correct and classic pattern, to give to my changeable green eyes the sea-blue tint and solemn lustre of his own. Not his ascendancy alone, however, held me in thrall at present. Of late it had been easy enough for me to look sad: Perhaps you think I had forgotten Mr. Rochester, reader, amidst these changes of place and fortune. Not for a moment. His idea was still with me, because it was not a vapour sunshine could disperse, nor a sand-traced effigy storms could wash away; it was a name graven on a tablet, fated to last as long as the marble it inscribed.

The craving to know what had become of him followed me everywhere; when I was at Morton, I re-entered my cottage every evening to think of that; and now at Moor House, I sought my bedroom each night to brood over it. In the course of my necessary correspondence with Mr.

Briggs about the will, I had inquired if he knew anything of Mr. Rochester's present residence and state of health; but, as St. John had conjectured, he was quite ignorant of all concerning him. I then wrote to Mrs. Fairfax, entreating information on the subject. I had calculated with certainty on this step answering my end: I felt sure it would elicit an early answer. I was astonished when a fortnight passed without reply; but when two months wore away, and day after day the post arrived and brought nothing for me, I fell a prey to the keenest anxiety.

Renewed hope followed renewed effort: When half a year wasted in vain expectancy, my hope died out, and then I felt dark indeed. A fine spring shone round me, which I could not enjoy.

Chapter XXXIV [St. John Rivers proposes marriage] from Charlotte Brontë's Jane Eyre

Summer approached; Diana tried to cheer me: John opposed; he said I did not want dissipation, I wanted employment; my present life was too purposeless, I required an aim; and, I suppose, by way of supplying deficiencies, he prolonged still further my lessons in Hindostanee, and grew more urgent in requiring their accomplishment: One day I had come to my studies in lower spirits than usual; the ebb was occasioned by a poignantly felt disappointment. Hannah had told me in the morning there was a letter for me, and when I went down to take it, almost certain that the long-looked for tidings were vouchsafed me at last, I found only an unimportant note from Mr.

The bitter check had wrung from me some tears; and now, as I sat poring over the crabbed characters and flourishing tropes of an Indian scribe, my eyes filled again.

John called me to his side to read; in attempting to do this my voice failed me: He and I were the only occupants of the parlour: Diana was practising her music in the drawing-room, Mary was gardening — it was a very fine May day, clear, sunny, and breezy. My companion expressed no surprise at this emotion, nor did he question me as to its cause; he only said — "We will wait a few minutes, Jane, till you are more composed. Having stifled my sobs, wiped my eyes, and muttered something about not being very well that morning, I resumed my task, and succeeded in completing it.

John put away my books and his, locked his desk, and said — "Now, Jane, you shall take a walk; and with me. Put on your things; go out by the kitchen-door: I will join you in a moment.

I never in my life have known any medium in my dealings with positive, hard characters, antagonistic to my own, between absolute submission and determined revolt.

ENGLISH LIT - Jane Eyre - John Mullan

I have always faithfully observed the one, up to the very moment of bursting, sometimes with volcanic vehemence, into the other; and as neither present circumstances warranted, nor my present mood inclined me to mutiny, I observed careful obedience to St. John's directions; and in ten minutes I was treading the wild track of the glen, side by side with him.

The breeze was from the west: As we advanced and left the track, we trod a soft turf, mossy fine and emerald green, minutely enamelled with a tiny white flower, and spangled with a star-like yellow blossom: John, as we reached the first stragglers of a battalion of rocks, guarding a sort of pass, beyond which the beck rushed down a waterfall; and where, still a little farther, the mountain shook off turf and flower, had only heath for raiment and crag for gem — where it exaggerated the wild to the savage, and exchanged the fresh for the frowning — where it guarded the forlorn hope of solitude, and a last refuge for silence.

I took a seat: John stood near me.

Why St. John Rivers Isn't Just a Jerk in Jane Eyre

He looked up the pass and down the hollow; his glance wandered away with the stream, and returned to traverse the unclouded heaven which coloured it: He seemed in communion with the genius of the haunt: An austere patriot's passion for his fatherland! He sat down; for half-an-hour we never spoke; neither he to me nor I to him: I am the servant of an infallible Master. I am not going out under human guidance, subject to the defective laws and erring control of my feeble fellow-worms: It seems strange to me that all round me do not burn to enlist under the same banner, — to join in the same enterprise.

I address only such as are worthy of the work, and competent to accomplish it. I trembled to hear some fatal word spoken which would at once declare and rivet the spell. It was as if I had heard a summons from Heaven — as if a visionary messenger, like him of Macedonia, had enounced, "Come over and help us! He continued — "God and nature intended you for a missionary's wife.

It is not personal, but mental endowments they have given you: A missionary's wife you must — shall be. You shall be mine: I claim you — not for my pleasure, but for my Sovereign's service. I have no vocation," I said. He had calculated on these first objections: Indeed, as he leaned back against the crag behind him, folded his arms on his chest, and fixed his countenance, I saw he was prepared for a long and trying opposition, and had taken in a stock of patience to last him to its close — resolved, however, that that close should be conquest for him.

Who is fit for it? Or who, that ever was truly called, believed himself worthy of the summons? I, for instance, am but dust and ashes. Paul, I acknowledge myself the chiefest of sinners; but I do not suffer this sense of my personal vileness to daunt me.

I know my Leader: Think like me, Jane — trust like me. It is the Rock of Ages I ask you to lean on: I have never studied missionary labours. I can set you your task from hour to hour; stand by you always; help you from moment to moment. This I could do in the beginning: I do not feel them. Nothing speaks or stirs in me while you talk. I am sensible of no light kindling — no life quickening — no voice counselling or cheering. Oh, I wish I could make you see how much my mind is at this moment like a rayless dungeon, with one shrinking fear fettered in its depths — the fear of being persuaded by you to attempt what I cannot accomplish!

I have watched you ever since we first met: I have made you my study for ten months. I have proved you in that time by sundry tests: In the village school I found you could perform well, punctually, uprightly, labour uncongenial to your habits and inclinations; I saw you could perform it with capacity and tact: In the calm with which you learnt you had become suddenly rich, I read a mind clear of the vice of Demas: In the resolute readiness with which you cut your wealth into four shares, keeping but one to yourself, and relinquishing the three others to the claim of abstract justice, I recognised a soul that revelled in the flame and excitement of sacrifice.

In the tractability with which, at my wish, you forsook a study in which you were interested, and adopted another because it interested me; in the untiring assiduity with which you have since persevered in it — in the unflagging energy and unshaken temper with which you have met its difficulties — I acknowledge the complement of the qualities I seek.

Jane, you are docile, diligent, disinterested, faithful, constant, and courageous; very gentle, and very heroic: As a conductress of Indian schools, and a helper amongst Indian women, your assistance will be to me invaluable. Shut my eyes as I would, these last words of his succeeded in making the way, which had seemed blocked up, comparatively clear.

My work, which had appeared so vague, so hopelessly diffuse, condensed itself as he proceeded, and assumed a definite form under his shaping hand. He waited for an answer. I demanded a quarter of an hour to think, before I again hazarded a reply.