an inspector calls - Does Eric Birling rape Eva Smith? - Literature Stack Exchange
Like for instance if Eva Smith was of a higher class Gerald arguably would never of the relationship she was back exactly where she started - selling herself in. Through Mr Birling's thoughtless actions of firing Eva Smith, his inability to admit his partial Pg 2: Showing off to Gerald Croft 'Giving us the port Edna?' . articles, student advice); Search by keyword (e.g. Eric, Class or Responsibility): . GERALD CROFT is an attractive chap about thirty, rather too manly to be a dandy but very When you're married you'll realize that men with important work to do .. Inspector: This young women, Eva Smith, was out of the ordinary. Birling: Oh – just before you came – I'd been giving these young men a little good advice.
This girl's still dead, isn't she?
Mr. Birling and Sheila assignment on how they treated Eva Smith.
Nobody's brought her to life, have they? He asks the stark question 'This girl's still dead, isn't she? Social and historical context J B Priestley uses Eric as he does Sheila - to suggest that the young people of a post-war Britain would be the answer to a hopeful future.
With Eric he also addresses some concerns he had about the dangers of immoral behaviour. Through Eric, Priestley shows that excessive drinking and casual relationships can have consequences. Analysing the evidence quote Whoever that chap was, the fact remains that I did what I did. And mother did what she did. And the rest of you did what you did to her. It's still the same rotten story whether it's been told to a police inspector or to somebody else.
According to you, I ought to feel a lot better - To Gerald I stole some money, Gerald, you might as well know - As Birling tries to interrupt. I don't care, let him know. The money's not the important thing. It's what happened to the girl and what we all did to her that matters.
And I still feel the same about it, and that's why I don't feel like sitting down and having a nice cosy talk.
BBC Bitesize - GCSE English Literature - Characters - AQA - Revision 6
Eric Birling How does Eric stand up to his parents in Act 3 of the play? Reveal answer down How to analyse the quotation: According to you, I ought to feel a lot better - To Gerald. I stole some money, Gerald, you might as well know - As Birling tries to interrupt. And the rest of you did what you did to her" - Eric repeats his point to add emphasis.
How to use this in an essay: At the start of the play, Eric tries to stand up his father but lacks the confidence to do it. After the truth about Eva Smith has come out, he has grown up enough to confidently state his point 'I did what I did. And the rest of you did what you did to her', the repetition of 'I did', 'she did' and 'you did' shows that Eric is clear in his mind who is to blame for the death of Eva Smith.
He describes the episode as a 'rotten story', the word 'rotten' is very emotive, he wants to let his parents know exactly how he feels. He lets himself down in the final act by trying to get the family out of trouble, he doesn't seem to have learned from his mistakes. How is Gerald Croft like this? Evidence Analysis Confident At the start of the play he seems very comfortable - making himself at home and behaving like a member of the Birling family he even makes fun of Eric.
Gerald confidently makes a joke at Eric's expense which is full of irony.An Inspector Calls – Episode 5: Gerald Croft
Evasive At first, when the truth comes out about his affair with Eva Smith he tries to avoid the subject. Honest Eventually Gerald gains some respect from Sheila and the audience for being honest about his affair. He was in the wrong to have an affair and then abandon Eva but, his use of emotive language 'cry for help' makes us realise that he genuinely felt sorry for her and wanted to help her.
Social and historical context Priestley uses Gerald to attack the upper-classes of post-war Britain. He shows that despite outward appearances, Gerald is described as an 'attractive chap' and 'well-bred'. This class of people were still capable of questionable behaviour.
Gerald has an affair and initially tries to avoid telling the truth. Priestley also suggests that they saw themselves above the problems of the working-classes - Gerald tries to get himself and the Birlings out of trouble. Analysing the evidence quote steadily I discovered, not that night but two nights later, when we met again — not accidentally this time of course - that in fact she hadn't a penny and was going to be turned out of the miserable back room she had.
It happened that a friend of mine, Charlie Brunswick, had gone off to Canada for six months and had let me have the key of a nice little set of rooms he had — in Morgan Terrace — and had asked me to keep an eye on them for him and use them if I wanted to. So I insisted on Daisy moving into those rooms and I made her take some money to keep her going there.
Carefully, to the Inspector. I want you to understand that I didn't install her there so that I could make love to her.